For a long time, borderline personality disorder (BPD) was considered one of the most difficult mental health conditions to treat. Some therapists even believed that people with BPD couldn't get better.
Fortunately, decades of research have demonstrated otherwise.
Today, we have several treatments that can help people with BPD manage intense emotions, build healthier relationships, reduce impulsive behaviors, and improve their quality of life.
Dialectical Behavior Therapy (DBT) is probably the best known, but it's not the only option. Here are five approaches worth considering if you’re looking for the right care for you or a loved one.
1. Dialectical Behavior Therapy (DBT)
Dialectical Behavior Therapy (DBT) was a game-changer for the treatment landscape for BPD. Developed by psychologist Marsha Linehan in the early 1990s, DBT was the first intervention for BPD that was explicitly tested in clinical trials.
The results were incredibly promising. Among chronically suicidal women with BPD, those receiving DBT were less likely to engage in self-harm, had fewer psychiatric hospitalizations, and were more likely to stay in treatment than those receiving usual care.
Since that initial study, DBT has been evaluated in more than 80 randomized clinical trials. Its strongest evidence is for reducing suicidal and self-injurious behaviors; however, promising data suggest that its effects extend to other problems, including substance use, eating disorders, and depression. DBT has also been successfully adapted for adolescents experiencing significant emotional and behavioral difficulties.
DBT is based on the idea that people with BPD experience emotions particularly intensely and often haven't had the support they need to learn effective ways of managing them. As a result, they may turn to strategies that provide relief in the moment but create additional problems in the long run.
So what actually happens during DBT? In the comprehensive version of treatment, you'll attend individual therapy at least once a week. Together with your therapist, you'll review difficulties from the previous week and identify more effective ways of responding.
For example, instead of binge eating after an argument with a friend, you might practice asking for what you need more assertively. Or you might learn strategies for tolerating the emotions
The strategies you'll practice in individual therapy are taught in weekly group skills training, where you'll learn four main sets of skills: mindfulness, emotion regulation, distress tolerance, and interpersonal effectiveness.
You'll also have access to between-session phone coaching to help you apply these skills when you need them most.
Comprehensive DBT typically lasts about a year, although some programs are shorter.
2. Mentalization-Based Treatment (MBT)
Mentalization-Based Treatment (MBT) was developed by psychologist Peter Fonagy and psychiatrist Anthony Bateman in the late 1990s. Randomized clinical trials have demonstrated improvements in BPD symptoms, self-harm, and interpersonal functioning.
MBT focuses on improving mentalizing, or our ability to understand our own thoughts and feelings and those of other people. Rather than teaching specific coping skills, as occurs in DBT, therapists help patients become better at understanding themselves and others through their interactions in session.
For example, imagine leaving a session convinced your therapist was annoyed with you. Rather than simply reassuring you that they weren't, an MBT therapist might explore what happened, how you interpreted the interaction, and what each of you might have been thinking or feeling.
The therapeutic relationship becomes a place to practice navigating emotionally charged interactions. Over time, patients become better at understanding and managing their own emotions, seeking support from others, and responding more flexibly in relationships.
MBT typically involves weekly individual and group sessions over 12–18 months.
3. Transference-Focused Psychotherapy (TFP)
Transference-Focused Psychotherapy (TFP) was developed by psychiatrist Otto Kernberg and colleagues. Randomized clinical trials have demonstrated improvements in BPD symptoms, including suicidality, aggression, and interpersonal functioning.
Like MBT, TFP focuses on helping people with BPD better understand themselves and their relationships, rather than teaching specific coping skills as in DBT. However, TFP is based on the idea that people with BPD have difficulty integrating positive and negative perceptions of themselves and others into a consistent picture.
For example, someone with BPD might see their partner as loving and trustworthy one moment, but cruel and uncaring after a disagreement. TFP aims to help patients recognize that both positive and negative qualities can exist in the same person.
So what actually happens during TFP? Like MBT, the therapeutic relationship is central to treatment. Therapists pay particular attention to how patients experience and respond to them, using these interactions to identify patterns that also occur in other relationships.
Over time, the goal is to help patients develop a more stable, integrated understanding of themselves and others, leading to greater emotional stability and healthier relationships.
Treatment typically involves twice-weekly individual sessions and often lasts a year or longer.
4. Good Psychiatric Management (GPM)
Developed by John Gunderson, GPM takes a practical approach to treating BPD that can be delivered by clinicians without extensive training in a specialized psychotherapy.
GPM emphasizes understanding BPD, developing a collaborative treatment plan, and helping patients improve their functioning in everyday life.
Particular attention is given to relationships, work, school, and other meaningful activities.
Rather than requiring therapists to learn an entirely new set of specialized techniques, GPM provides a structured framework for applying sound clinical principles to the treatment of BPD.
One important study compared GPM directly with DBT and found that both treatments produced substantial improvements, including reductions in suicidal and self-injurious behaviors.
This finding challenged the assumption that effective BPD treatment necessarily requires a highly specialized, intensive treatment program.
5. BPD Compass
BPD Compass is a newer cognitive-behavioral treatment that my colleagues and I developed to make evidence-based care for BPD more efficient and accessible.
Across decades of BPD treatment research, we were intrigued by the fact that DBT, MBT, TFP, and GPM all produce meaningful improvements, with no single approach consistently outperforming the others. This suggests that each of these treatments addresses something important about BPD, whether that’s emotion regulation (DBT), relational functioning (MBT, TFP), or building a life worth living (GPM).
At the same time, many patients continue to experience significant symptoms even after treatment. We wondered if non-optimal response rates could be due to a mismatch between the problems driving an individual client’s symptoms and the treatment they received. For example, a patient who struggles most with trust would likely be a good fit for MBT or TFP - but what if the only treatment in their city was DBT?
We developed BPD Compass to be a comprehensive treatment package with modules to address emotion dysregulation, relational difficulties/attachment, and impulsivity (an important, but understudied driver of BPD symptoms). We also include values identification, aligned with GPM’s focus on building a life worth living.
We start treatment with assessment to figure out what is driving your BPD symptoms and then develop a treatment plan so you receive the modules that are most relevant to you. This personalization makes treatment more efficient. BPD Compass is delivered in 18 sessions, making it considerably shorter than many traditional BPD treatments. And, like GPM, it was developed so that generalist clinicians would be able to deliver it without the intensive training required for DBT, MBT, and TFP.
In an initial randomized clinical trial, people receiving BPD Compass showed large improvements in BPD symptoms, as well as improvements in emotional, relational, and impulsive functioning. And improvements in commonly co-occurring conditions like depression, anxiety, eating disorders, and substance use disorders.
Which Treatment Is Best for Me?
The encouraging news is that people with BPD have more evidence-based treatment options than ever before. However, that doesn't mean every treatment is equally appropriate for every person.
BPD is an incredibly heterogeneous condition. Some people experience frequent suicidal crises and need intensive, long-term support. Others may be able to make meaningful progress with a shorter intervention.
As a BPD treatment developer, my goal isn't to replace DBT, MBT, TFP, or GPM with BPD Compass. It's to expand the options available. Not everyone with BPD needs twice-weekly therapy for a year or more, and I believe we should have effective, personalized alternatives for those who don't.
Ultimately, the best treatment is one that addresses your particular difficulties, provides the level of support you need, and is accessible enough for you to actually receive it.
Next Steps
Learn more about BPD Compass: Explore the treatment, the research behind it, and how it works. Learn more about BPD Compass.
Learn more about the Compass Companion: Despite advances in BPD treatment, many people still don't have access to trained providers in their area. The Compass Companion is a self-help resource designed to help people begin addressing BPD symptoms, even when specialized treatment isn't readily available. Learn more about the Compass Companion.